Skip to main content

Property Management Blog

5 Red Flags to Look for During a Tenant Criminal Background Check

5 Red Flags to Look for During a Tenant Criminal Background Check

5 Red Flags to Look for During a Tenant Criminal Background Check

It's shocking that around 2.7 million households face eviction each year in America.

No rental property owner ever wants to be in this position. Going through the legal eviction process takes a toll on someone's emotions, finances, and security. This is why rental property owners can't cut any corners when it comes to tenant screening.

The reason why tenant screening is vital is that you can feel more confident when choosing tenants. After a tenant criminal background check, you'll have plenty of information to move forward or decline an applicant. Read on to uncover five renter red flags to look out for while you screen.

1. Several Criminal Convictions

One of the primary reasons for conducting a criminal background check is to identify any criminal convictions in a potential tenant's history. Several convictions, especially for serious offenses, should raise a red flag.

While people can make mistakes, repeated criminal behavior may indicate a pattern that could pose a risk to your property or other tenants.

2. An Eviction History

An eviction history is a colossal red flag during a tenant criminal background check. It suggests that the applicant has a track record of not fulfilling their rental obligations. This could be due to the following:

  • Non-payment of rent
  • Property damage
  • Other lease violations

As an investment property owner, you want tenants who are reliable and fulfill their contractual agreements. An eviction history may indicate a higher likelihood of future problems.

3. False Information on the Application

Pay attention to inconsistencies or false information on the tenant's application. This could include the following:

  • Providing incorrect employment details
  • Inflating income
  • Misrepresenting their rental history

Tenants who provide false information may be attempting to hide something or secure a property under false pretenses. Verifying the accuracy of the information provided is key when it comes to securing responsible tenants.

4. Outstanding Warrants or Pending Charges

Discovering outstanding warrants or pending criminal charges during a background check is a clear red flag. It indicates that the tenant may be facing legal issues that hurt their ability to fulfill their lease obligations.

While everyone is innocent until proven guilty, pending charges or warrants should prompt further investigation and consideration before approving a tenant application.

5. A Pattern of Property Damage

A tenant's criminal history may also reveal a pattern of property damage. This includes offenses such as vandalism or destruction of property. Property owners should be cautious about renting to individuals with a history of causing damage to rental units.

Such behavior poses a risk not only to the property but also to the relationship with other tenants.

You Can't Ignore These Signs During a Tenant Criminal Background Check

Conducting a thorough tenant criminal background check is an essential step. It's what will keep your investment and other tenants safe. Being aware of these renter red flags will keep you out of trouble.

Have you ever felt like you need help with rental property management? Contact Red Team to hear about our amazing property management solutions. We've been helping investors in the Dallas Fort Worth area like you since 2012.